Consign to Paragon Auctions February 25, 2019 Auction – Deadline January 24th

Be a part of our February 25, 2019 auction & consign with Paragon Auctions.  Calling all consignors! We’re busy preparing our next auction. Now is the time to add your consignments to our next auction, we’re looking for all major sports memorabilia, game used, vintage trading card sets, graded cards, autographs, championship rings, and awards.

We’re often asked, what’s the difference between these BIG auction houses and smaller boutique auction house like ours? Big auction houses are great if you’re interested in your lots competing against 2,000 other lots and/or if you’d like your items competing against other consignors material in the same auction (i.e. – an auction offering 25 different Babe Ruth single signed baseballs or an auction house offering a half a dozen 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle cards).

Now, we would never tell you where to consign your treasured items, but at we pledge to our clients that we will keep our auction to no more than 500 lots per auction. This way your items do not get lost in a vast sea of sports memorabilia. Our bidders will not become overwhelmed with an overabundance of choices.

We specialize in game used bats, game used jerseys, NASCAR, trophies, rings, graded cards, and autographs. We offer one free LOA on consigned autographs and game used bats. Please ask for more details.  We also are looking for collections and offer finder fees on collections or single items.  Our customer service is second-to-none and we treat our consignors like we would like to be treated and will always be willing to work with you on your items.

We are currently looking for:
  • Game used equipment from Hall of Fame players or stars in any sport.
  • Championship awards from any sport.
  • Single-signed baseballs or team-signed.
  • Pre-1969 baseball cards or sets.


  • We offer one of the best consignment rates in the hobby.
  • We start paying consignors in 21 days after the close of the auction.
  • No duplication of items.
  • Customer service: we treat your collection as if it was ours and live by the golden rule – treat others as you want to be treated.
  • Auction Letter of Authenticity (ALOA) provided at no charge for all autographed items or game used bat authentications; saving you, in turn, hundreds to thousands of dollars!

There is also no charge on LOA’s unless you want a full letter or your bat graded, then you will be charged what we are charged.   Any questions please call Keith Vari at 732-261-9355 or email

Please visit our website at:
We are not the typical auction house as we only take items we feel we will get you top dollar for as we know what we do best with. With Paragon it is not all about the money, it is customer service and making sure consignors are happy.

We are seeking:

  • Vintage Sports Cards
  • Game Used Jerseys
  • Game Used Bats
  • Awards and Jewelry
  • Game Used and Awards From Basketball and Football

Individual lot consignments we try to keep a value over $500 and higher.

Consigning to Paragon is Simple
You can either Email us at with a description of the item you would like to consign and if you have photos that would help in Paragon give you a more precise value. Please include your contact information and we will call you back. If we agree on you consigning with Paragon we will send you a contract to sign and you can send your item to Paragon with the signed contract.

We have specialized in selling items/collections fresh to the hobby as these seem to do 25%-50% better than if your items are sold individually.
The auction is an online auction and you will be able to view your consignments throughout the auction. We will also email you your descriptions for you to review before the auction starts.

We also Purchase items Outright
Some clients do not want to wait for the auction and just want to sell outright.  We are always purchasing items outright for private sales or for the auction. We have purchased single items and collections from many high profile players including Tony Dorsett, Tim Brown, Horace Grant and Deion Sanders family member.

If you have items for sale or are looking for appraisals please contact us. We will make a fair offer that will make everybody happy.  Please contact us with any questions – including free appraisals. Check out our website for more information at


Featured Auctions

(*) Indicates Auction in Progress
(*) PWCC: June 1 - June 20
(*) RR Auction: June 13 - June 20
(*) Sirius Sports: June 10 - June 20
(*) Sterling Sports Auction: June 6 - June 20
(*) NHL Auctions - Blues: June 1 - June 21
(*) Iconic Auctions: June 13 - June 22
(*) SCP Auctions: June 5 - June 22
(*) Heritage Historical: June 3 - June 22-23
(*) PWCC: June 1 - June 23-27
(*) NHL Auctions: June 12 - June 24
(*) University Archives: June 5 - June 26
(*) NHL Auctions - Blues: June 1 - June 26-28
(*) Small Traditions: June 16 - June 29
(*) Pristine - Elite: June 1 - June 30
(*) PWCC: June 1 - June 30
(*) Sirius Coins: June 17 - June 30
Sirius Sports: June 23 - July 4
MEARS Auctions: June 28 - July 6
PWCC: July 1 - July 8-11
(*) June 12 - July 9
(*) MeiGray Auctions: June 16 - July 9
(*) Clean Sweep Auctions: June 6 - July 10
RR Auction: June 21 - July 10
Mile High Card Co: June 24 - July 11
Sirius Coins: July 1 - July 14
PWCC: July 1 - July 14-18
Grey Flannel: June 26 - July 17
Collect Auctions: July 1 - July 18
RR Auction: July 11 - July 18
Sirius Sports: July 6 - July 18
Heritage Historical: June 27 - July 16-18
Heritage Sports: June 26 - July 18-19
Iconic Auctions: July 10 - July 20
PWCC: July 1 - July 21-25
Pristine - Elite: July 1 - July 28
Sirius Coins: July 15 - July 28
PWCC: July 1 - July 28-31
Goldin Auctions: July 8 - Aug. 1
Sirius Sports: July 20 - Aug. 1
Iconic Auctions: July 24 - Aug. 3
MEARS Auctions: July 26 - Aug. 3
NSCC - Charity: July 1 - Aug. 3
2019 Full Auction Schedule