The 1909 E92 Dockman & Sons Honus Wagner Collection

Just Collect Buys Vintage Card Collection Featuring 1915 Cracker Jack & T206’sLast week, Just Collect acquired these two incredible cards from a long time collector, who resides in the New England area. Usually, when someone contacts us about selling their baseball cards, it’s usually a collection of Hall of Famers, or a run of vintage sets. Conversely, this collector had a smaller collection of cards, but only wanted to sell a few. When I was young, the only cards I was willing to sell were groups of commons and of my lower end cards, and I’d keep all the valuable ones.

The thought process was, that if I could sell just my large group of commons or minor stars and keep the great ones, not only would I get the money I needed, but I’d keep the most attractive cards in my collection. That was my mindset. And to this day, if we are just talking about money and future value, I would use that same approach – “less is more”. The collector who sold these gems to Just Collect, had a different view.

He’s not in it for money, or for a future investment, or banking on these for his retirement – he just needed a little extra cash. Which is why he decided to sell TWO OF HIS BEST CARDS, and kept the rest. He couldn’t fathom parting ways with his entire collection of E92 Dockman’s, M116 Sporting Life’s, T206?s and other tobacco era cards that were passed down from down from his Grandfather. At the end of the day, he could either have a few cards left in his collection, or the majority of the cards, and he chose the latter.

justcollect7-21-14

 

To say this collector has discipline, would be an understatement. I love this guy’s moxie, and he’s undoubtedly, the epitome of a true hobbyist. I would also like to note, that many of the other cards in his collection were “marked” by his grandfather – a simple inscription signifying the position the athlete played that identified that the cards were his. In the collecting world, this is “no-no”, and is deemed to decrease the value of the cards.

But to the owner, the personal appeal and connection to his Grandfather had a far greater sentimental value. This is another reason why he chose to keep the majority of the cards. The two cards that he did part ways with were “clean” and have no markings on them. He could now keep the rest of the cards in his collection and his Grandfather’s memory could live on forever.

As always, knowing the sentimental value, we made the process of selling his prized possessions as easy as possible as the seller noted:
“Scott did a nice job evaluating each and every card in the collection of cards I had. The M-116?s, Dockman E-92?s and the T-206?s were passed on to me by my grandfather. The mark on the back of the Honus Wagner M-116, while “degrading” the value of the card for sale, actually increased the value to me personally. Thinking of my grandfather handling my/his cards was a neat memory. Thanks Scott”

How great are these two cards you ask? Pretty outstanding. Let’s take a look: Both of these cards come from the 1909 E92 Dockman & Son’s set – and both are of Honus Wagner. The compendium of E92?s are actually identified by their premium sponsored reverses, which include Dockman & Sons, Nadja Caramels, Croft’s Cocoa and Croft’s Candy advertising backs. The front of each card is consistent throughout each manufacturer, while the back is unique to it’s own. These two particular examples, hail from from the 1909 Dockman & Son’s premiums that is complete with 40 different cards (the Croft’s premiums contain a total of 50 cards, while the Nadja Caramels backs feature the most players, containing a total of 62 cards.)

Together, there are less than 100 examples of the Wagner card encapsulated by PSA, with somewhere around 80% being of low grade. Which is exactly why we were so eager to get these cards in. Both examples that we have are mid-grade or higher, which, for the time period, is incredible. The first card is the Honus Wagner “batting” variation. This card is a beauty, presenting with minimal surface wear, slightly rounded corners, and no print defects or paper loss! The card still retains it’s vibrant red colored background, making Wagner, and his jersey, “pop” off the card. The second card is the “throwing” variation of Wagner.

I can honestly say that I don’t think I have ever seen a more perfectly centered E92 Dockman than this one right here. Again, a nice mid-grade example, with minimal wear, and superb eye appeal. Imagine adding this one to your collection! The “batting” variation is easily the scarcest of the two Wagners, and will draw tremendous attention throughout the hobby. It is so rare in fact, that one hasn’t been made available to the public since 2010! We are very excited to see how this card will grade, and we will definitely let you know when we put it up for auction.

The “throwing” variation is also very hard to find, as only a few examples pop up each year for sale and garner thousands of dollars when they do. Regardless if you are a Wagner collector, a Hall of Fame collector, or just a fan of the hobby, both of these cards will add tremendous value to your collection. Even though this was a small acquisition, we were still very excited to be able to purchase them, because the cards are highly valuable.

Be sure to check out our eBay store for these cards, and other tobacco and candy cards! Just Collect is always buying vintage sports and non-sports cards from 1879-1979.

News by Company & Category

Featured Auctions

(*) Indicates Auction in Progress
(*) Auction of Champions: July 11 - July 17
(*) Steve Novella: July 9 - July 17
(*) MeiGray Auctions: June 26 - July 17-18
(*) Alt Liquid Auctions: July 5 - July 18
(*) Fanatics Collect: July 4 - July 18
(*) Goldin: July 9 - July 18
(*) RR Auction: June 18 - July 18
(*) Gotta Have Rock & Roll: July 3 - July 19
(*) Galaxy Auctions: July 10 - July 20
(*) Goldin: July 3 - July 20
(*) 44 & More Auctions: June 24 - July 21
(*) Evans Archives: July 15 - July 21
(*) Fanatics Collect: July 11 - July 21
(*) Greg Morris Marketplace: July 15 - July 21
(*) Icons Auctions: July 15 - July 21
(*) Pristine Auction: July 15 - July 21
(*) Queen City Cards: June 24 - July 21
(*) MeiGray Auctions: July 5 - July 23-24
Auction of Champions: July 18 - July 24
(*) Goldin: July 16 - July 25
(*) Sirius Sports Cards: July 15 - July 25
Iconic Auctions: July 20 - July 27
The National Charity Auction: July 20 - July 27
(*) 44 & More Auctions: June 24 - July 28
Evans Archives: July 22 - July 28
Fanatics Collect: July 18 - July 28
Greg Morris Marketplace: July 22 - July 28
Icons Auctions: July 22 - July 28
(*) Pristine Auction: July 1 - July 28
Pristine Auction: July 22 - July 28
(*) Queen City Cards: June 24 - July 28
(*) Fanatics Auctions: July 16 - July 29
Auction of Champions: July 25 - July 31
(*) Eaton & Brennan Auctions: July 17 - July 31
Alt Liquid Auctions: July 19 - Aug. 1
Huggins & Scott: July 19 - Aug. 1
NBA Auctions: July 20 - Aug. 1
Sterling Sports Auctions: July 18 - Aug. 1
(*) Goldin: July 15 - Aug. 3
MEARS Auctions: July 26 - Aug. 3
(*) SCP Auctions: July 17 - Aug. 3
(*) The Collector Connection: July 17 - Aug. 4
Evans Archives: July 29 - Aug. 4
Fanatics Collect: July 25 - Aug. 4
Greg Morris Marketplace: July 29 - Aug. 4
Icons Auctions: July 29 - Aug. 4
Pristine Auction: July 29 - Aug. 4
(*) Wheatland Auction Services: July 8 - Aug. 4
Auction of Champions: Aug. 1 - Aug. 7
RR Auction: July 19 - Aug. 7
(*) University Archives: July 17 - Aug. 7
(*) Clean Sweep Auctions: July 17 - Aug. 7-8
Sirius Sports Cards: July 29 - Aug. 8
(*) Queen City Cards: July 8 - Aug. 11
REA: July 23 - Aug. 11
2024 Full Auction Schedule